Home  /  Free Tools  /  S-Corp vs LLC Calculator

Free tool, no email required

S-Corp vs LLC Tax Savings Calculator

An S corporation election can cut self-employment tax, but it also adds payroll, a separate return and real admin. This works out whether the saving is actually worth it for your numbers.

Your numbers

Four inputs, that is all

$

Profit after expenses, before any owner salary.

$

The IRS requires this to be reasonable for the work you do. Too low invites scrutiny.

$

Payroll processing, the 1120-S return and state fees. Varies a lot by state.

$

Some states charge an S corp minimum regardless of profit. California is the well known one.

Estimated annual difference

$0

Enter your numbers to see the comparison.

Self-employment tax as an LLC$0
Payroll tax on your salary$0
Extra cost of the S corp$0
 

This compares self-employment tax against payroll tax on a salary, plus the running cost of the election. It does not model income tax, the qualified business income deduction, state income tax, or your personal circumstances, all of which can change the answer. Treat it as a starting point for a conversation, not as tax advice.

How it works

What this is actually comparing

As an LLC, all profit is exposed

Self-employment tax applies to your whole net profit: 12.4% Social Security up to the annual wage base, plus 2.9% Medicare on everything, with an extra 0.9% above higher thresholds.

As an S corp, only the salary is

You pay yourself a salary that carries payroll tax. What is left over is taken as a distribution, which does not carry self-employment tax. That gap is the whole saving.

Then the costs come off

Running payroll, filing an 1120-S, and any state minimum or franchise tax. Below roughly $40,000 to $50,000 of profit these usually swallow the saving.

Read this before deciding

The number is not the whole decision

Reasonable compensation is the part that gets people into trouble. Set the salary too low to boost the saving and the IRS can recharacterise distributions as wages, with back tax and penalties attached. There is no formula in the tax code for it, which is precisely why it needs a defensible basis rather than a number that makes the calculator look good.

The election also has a deadline, adds a separate corporate return, and is not trivially reversible. It is a structural decision, not a switch.

Want this modelled properly?

Tax Planning includes modelling both structures on your actual numbers, with reasonable compensation documented rather than guessed.

Other free tools

Get a straight answer on your own numbers

A short call, an honest read, and a straight no if the election would not be worth it for you.

Scroll to Top
Book a Free Consultation