The most common sales tax problem we see is not evasion. It is a business that grew across state lines and had no idea an obligation had started.
Physical presence used to be the test
For decades, a state could only require you to collect sales tax if you had a physical connection to it: an office, a warehouse, staff, inventory. If you shipped into a state from elsewhere, that state generally could not reach you.
That changed in 2018. The Supreme Court decision in South Dakota v. Wayfair allowed states to base the obligation on economic activity instead of physical presence. Nearly every state with a sales tax adopted some version of it.
What economic nexus actually means
Each state sets a threshold, typically expressed as a dollar amount of sales into that state over a twelve month period, sometimes combined with or replaced by a transaction count. Cross it, and you are required to register, collect and file in that state.
The important details, and the ones that catch people out:
- Thresholds differ by state, and several states have changed theirs since 2018.
- Some states measure gross sales, others measure only taxable sales. The difference matters if much of what you sell is exempt.
- The measurement period is not always the calendar year.
- Crossing the threshold creates an obligation going forward from a specified point, not retroactively to your first sale, but the clock starts whether or not you noticed.
Marketplace sales complicate the picture
If you sell through a marketplace such as Amazon, the marketplace facilitator rules generally require the marketplace to collect and remit on those sales rather than you. That sounds like it removes the problem, and for the tax itself it largely does.
The complication is that in some states those marketplace sales still count toward your economic nexus threshold, even though you are not the one remitting on them. So a seller who is mostly on marketplaces can cross a threshold on marketplace volume and then owe on their direct website sales into that state. Tracking both streams separately is the only way to see this coming.
If you have already crossed a threshold and not filed
This is more common than you might think, and it is fixable. The important thing is that it gets worse with time, because penalties and interest accrue and the lookback period grows.
Most states operate voluntary disclosure programmes. Broadly, if you come forward before the state finds you, they will typically limit how far back you have to go and often abate penalties. If they find you first, neither of those is on the table.
Waiting is almost never the right call.
What to do first
Before registering anywhere, get an assessment. Pull your sales by state for the last two years and compare against each state’s threshold and measurement rules. Very often the answer is that you have obligations in fewer states than you feared, and registering in states where you do not owe creates filing requirements you then have to maintain forever.
Assess first, register second.



